Welcome to my book review for Where Only Storms Grow by Alyssa Colman. Thank you to NetGalley and Farrar, Straus and Giroux for providing an e-copy in exchange for an honest review.
Title: Where Only Storms Grow
Author: Alyssa Colman
Published by Farrar, Straus and Giroux on August 19, 2025
Goodreads
ISBN: 9780374392789
Genre: Historical Fiction
Intended Audience: Middle Grade
My Rating: ★★★★☆ 4 stars
Where Only Storms Grow Official Synopsis:
It’s been four years since rain fell on the Oklahoma Panhandle, and the closeness between the twelve-year-old Stanton twins has dried up as much as the land. Howe Stanton has been practicing running away and longs for the family to quit this land of dust and broken dreams. Despite the scoliosis that causes Joanna Stanton near-constant pain, she isn’t ready to give up like her brother. But when Daddy leaves the family behind to find work in California, saving the farm from ruin falls on Howe’s unwilling and Joanna’s uneven shoulders.
To pay the family’s debts, Joanna takes a job at the local hospital and discovers purpose helping others. Howe finds unexpected joy in caring for his father’s horse and by escaping in a borrowed book.
But then a tragedy in town reveals the dust’s deadly dangers. With the worst storm of the Dust Bowl bearing down on their home, Howe and Joanna must put aside their differences and work together, or everyone and everything they love will be lost to the dust.
Where Only Storms Grow Review:
As an environmentalist, the Dust Bowl is an era in American history that fascinates me to no end. While loads of sources will tell you about the millions of people who left their farms during the Dust Bowl, this novel focuses on a fictional family who stayed. In recent years, historical fiction novels have begun to grow on me, so I was all the more excited to give this one a read.
“It sounds to me like we’ve each been carrying the same burden separately. Maybe we should try sharing the load.” -Alyssa Colman, Where Only Storms Grow
Where Only Storms Grow is told from the perspectives of 12-year-old twins Joanna and Howe Stanton. Through circumstances both necessary and unfortunate, much of the burden to save their family’s farm falls onto the young twins. But their tense relationship and individual burdens make this task all the more daunting.
I found both Joanna and Howe to be compelling protagonists. While both twins face the same issue of saving the family farm, they also have their differences. Joanna and Howe have unique struggles, values, and aspirations that make each of their stories stand out. Howe’s dreams of being a writer pull at readers’ hearts, and his pain at being unable to pursue his passion is something to which many can relate. His yearning and passion are so vividly portrayed that you can’t help but root for him along his journey.
Howe’s twin sister, Joanna Stanton, is equally endearing. Smothered by her mother’s concern for her scoliosis, Joanna often feels frustrated and hopeless. But when she gets a job at a local hospital, the entire world begins to open up for her. Joanna’s character growth arc is nothing short of inspiring. And I don’t just mean that in the “disabled people are inspiring” way, but in the “I love stories about people who learn to see potential in the world” way. Through her work, Joanna finds meaning, and I connect with this concept on a personal level, making her story all the more meaningful.
“I wasn’t in any hurry to grow up — it seemed like I already had enough responsibilities as it was — but the thought of helping people and seeing a little bit of the world made the future feel like something it never had before: full of possibility.” -Alyssa Colman, Where Only Storms Grow
Of course, Joanna’s disability is also an excellent part of Where Only Storms Grow. Author Alyssa Colman also has scoliosis, and Joanna’s symptoms are largely based on her own. We all know that I’m a massive advocate for OwnVoices stories, and this is an excellent one. It’s so rare to see disabilities represented in novels (or maybe I’m just not reading the right novels), but Colman does an outstanding job of weaving Joanna’s scoliosis into her character and the overarching plot. I learned a lot about scoliosis specifically and also the social/emotional aspects of living with a physical disability.
Along the way, this book teaches about a lot more in addition to scoliosis. I found myself enthralled by Colman’s descriptions of the Dust Bowl storms, dust pneumonia, and how people dealt with the hardships of this man-made ecological disaster. The details that Colman provides not only bring the story to life, but also evoke eerily familiar images of climate change and pandemics that bind the story even more to the reader. I literally got chills when I read the painfully familiar line “We’re living in unprecedented times.”
Where Only Storms Grow‘s connections to the modern world help to nail in all its themes. This novel explores family dynamics, the power of hope, and community, among many other equally powerful topics. Every page includes something for readers to connect with and learn from. But it’s also not all doom and gloom! There’s plenty of comedic relief (I adore Ruby the indoor chicken!) and joyous moments to breathe a perfect amount of levity into a story that otherwise has the potential to be incredibly heavy.
Although I cherished this novel, I also have to mention the reason I can’t give it 5 stars: the ending. For a story with such emotional power and complex characters, the ending is rather abrupt and (dare I say) unsatisfying. Maybe this is just me wanting more of such an incredible story, but I wish there had been an extra chapter or two at the end to flesh out the impact of how everything wraps up. But other than that, I have few complaints.
Recommendation & Rating:
Overall, Where Only Storms Grow is an easily lovable and refreshingly thoughtful story. It is great for historical fiction lovers and super accessible for younger readers. This novel is easy to connect with and highly educational in so many ways. I highly recommend this book if you’re looking for stories about disabled characters or life during the Dust Bowl era.
“Asking for help isn’t giving up. It’s refusing to give up.” -Alyssa Colman, Where Only Storms Grow
My Rating: ★★★★☆ 4 stars
Thank you for reading my Where Only Storms Grow review. To read more of my book reviews, check out my Book Reviews page.